Want help choosing?
We don't sell individual cigars online, but please contact us for details on purchasing your favorite cigars in bulk -
These are some of our best-selling cigars - aka the ones customers keep coming back for. Whether you like smooth and creamy, dark and bold, big-ring bruisers, or sweet aromatics, this list is a safe bet.
Best Day Ever is our in-house cigar line featuring Dominican tobacco, built for easy enjoyment—great draw, approachable flavor, and an all-around “light it and relax” experience. If you’re visiting St. Thomas, this is the souvenir that actually gets used.
Our #1 best seller for a reason. Expect a mellow-to-medium smoke with a warm, rounded sweetness that plays nicely with a pour of rum, bourbon, or even coffee. If you’re buying a gift and don’t know someone’s preferences, start here.
Great for: new cigar smokers, vacation vibes, after-dinner smokes
A classic “morning to anytime” cigar. Smooth, easy, and not overpowering—think creamy texture, gentle cedar/nut notes, and a refined finish. This one turns “I don’t usually smoke cigars” into “Add two more.”
Great for: first-time smokers, daytime, golf, pairing with cappuccino
For people who want more depth. Expect bolder flavor—richer earth and cocoa vibes—with a satisfying “real cigar” presence while still staying smooth. A strong step up from Connecticut without getting harsh.
Great for: medium-bodied fans, evening smoke, bourbon/rye pairings
These are the cigars customers choose most often—fan favorites, repeat buys, and “I need another box” staples. If you’re browsing and don’t want to overthink it, start with anything below.
One of our most popular “I want something different” picks. Big flavor, big personality, and the kind of cigar people remember. If you like rich, punchy smokes, this one belongs in your rotation.
A timeless, approachable cigar with that traditional Romeo y Julieta style—smooth, balanced, and consistently enjoyable. Great when you want a dependable smoke that won’t overpower your palate.
Thick, dark, and satisfying—this is the “bang for your buck” maduro that keeps people coming back. If you like a heavier profile and a lot of smoke, Titan delivers.
The “treat yourself” cigar. Padrón is legendary for a reason—deep, refined flavor and a smoothness that feels expensive from the first draw to the last inch. Perfect for celebrations or a serious nightcap.
If you like flavored cigars that still feel well-made, this is the move. Creamy coffee sweetness with a relaxing aroma—great for social settings and after dinner.
A richer, more modern Montecristo experience—smooth but complex, with a premium feel. This is for the smoker who wants quality and character in the same stick.
Rocky Patel fans know the vibe: strong construction, big flavor, and a finish that lingers in a good way. If you like robust profiles and thicker rings, Disciple Sixty hits the spot.
A go-to recommendation for “I want something nice.” Fuente’s Hemingway line is famous for its refined, smooth character and top-tier consistency. Signature gives you a longer sit; Short Story is perfect when time is tight.
A reliable crowd-pleaser with a softer, creamier personality. Great for newer smokers and anyone who prefers smooth flavor over heavy strength.
One of the most respected names in modern premium cigars. Expect richness and complexity without harshness— a cigar that feels like it costs more than it does.
A top seller for people who want a sweeter smoke with serious flavor and an unmistakable aroma. Great for parties, beach nights, and anyone who likes their cigar to announce itself.
A “nice but not fussy” cigar: smooth, flavorful, and easy to smoke. The tube makes it perfect for travel and gifting.
Benchmark for premium Nicaraguan cigars—rich, smooth, and special-occasion worthy (1964 & 1926).
Classic craftsmanship and elegance (Hemingway line is a must-try).
Iconic brand with both traditional and modern premium expressions (Espada, Classic, White).
A timeless “easy to enjoy” brand—great balance and approachable flavor (1875, Clemenceau).
Known for big flavor and reliable construction (Disciple, Vintage lines, Sixty formats).
Fan-favorite Nicaraguan profiles that deliver richness and value (Melanio, Serie G, Serie O).
Premium-grade craftsmanship with bold, modern blends (Alma Fuerte, Alma del Fuego).
Bold, full-flavored cigars built for experienced palates (The Judge, La Promesa, Flor de las Antillas).
Modern classics and top aromatics—Deadwood, Undercrown, ACID, and Java are always in demand.
Quality-forward blends that punch above their price (INCH, Pledge, Allegiance).
Polished, premium feel with rich complexity (VSG is a staple for fuller tastes).
Luxury cigars for when you want ultra-refined flavor and a special experience (Late Hour).
Start with something smooth and forgiving: Best Day Ever Connecticut, Perdomo Champagne, or Undercrown Shade. If you want a sweeter option, try Tabak Café con Leche or Deadwood.
Best Day Ever – Rum is a strong all-around gift pick. If you want premium, go with Padrón 1964. If they like smooth classics, Arturo Fuente Hemingway is almost always a win.
Yes—several of our best sellers are big ring favorites, including JFR Titan and multiple Rocky Patel “Sixty” formats.
Absolutely. Tell us what you like (or what you’ve hated) and we’ll recommend a few that match your flavor profile.
Sorry, there are no products in this collection